The Un-Community · Appendix B
The Guardrails Checklist
Not legal advice. This checklist collects the book's working positions so you can run through them at each stage of operating a room. It doesn't replace a lawyer, an accountant or a privacy professional. Where it says "ask a lawyer," it means one licensed where you work who knows the area in question. It's written for readers in the United States; elsewhere, the questions still apply, but the answers may differ.
If the answer to any question is "no" or "I'm not sure," stop until you've sorted it out.
Lines that don't move
- Never export, sell, trade or share a member list or member record, including between rooms you operate.
- Never take a secret cut. Members know how you're paid, and the owner agreed to it in writing.
- Never sell moderation. Nobody pays to have a post removed, a complaint hidden or a competitor banned.
- Never let members coordinate the prices they charge, divide customers or territories, share bids or boycott a supplier or competitor.
- Never put investing, lending, insurance or real estate on the exchange, and never pay or take fees for patient referrals.
- Never run a drawing that members pay to enter.
- Never make earnings or outcome claims to readers, members or owners.
- Never agree with another operator who pursues which owner. Compete for owners on your own, or part ways.
- Never pitch a community of your own as part of this work.
Before you take a room
- Does the owner know exactly what I'll build, what I won't touch, and how I'll report?
- Is there a written owner agreement covering scope, my share and what it's a share of, reporting, my right to see the numbers, member data, term, notice and exit? Does it say that I keep de-identified know-how (patterns about what works, with nothing that identifies a member and none of the owner's confidential numbers)?
- Have I read the platform's terms on commercial activity, automation, data export and paid tiers, and does what I plan to build fit them?
- Are the room's members adults? If the room includes minors, have I stepped back or talked to a lawyer first?
- Does the room trade in a licensed field, and have I kept those topics off the exchange?
- Would taking this room leave any one owner at or near a quarter of my earnings, rather than well under it?
Before you sort the room and spread the hosting
- Does the room's privacy note say that we keep a short note of roughly what stage each member seems to be at, and that members can see or remove theirs?
- Are member hosts and moderators volunteers, is the role never a condition of membership, and does it stay light? If hosts get free membership, pay, or a regular schedule of real work, have I asked a lawyer about volunteer and contractor rules?
Before you build the trading floor
- Do the board rules require quantified posts, expiry dates, and disclosure of any referral fee between members?
- Do board posts leave out the prices members charge their own customers (a need may state its budget)?
- Is the deal-room test menu free of list swaps?
- Does every endorsed send follow commercial-email rules (clear identification, a working unsubscribe, a physical address), disclose the paid link, and have a lawyer's answer on who counts as the sender?
- Do the room rules say plainly that group deals are about what members buy, never about what they charge?
- Is my good-faith check on posts described as exactly that, with no promise that members' claims are true?
Before you keep a member record
- Did members opt in, knowing what's on the record, who sees it and how to delete it?
- Am I keeping only the fields the job needs?
- Is the record secured, and does the owner agreement say who holds it and what happens to it at exit?
- If members live in places with stricter privacy laws, have I asked a privacy lawyer how to handle them?
- Would I be comfortable if a member read every note on their own page?
Before you get paid
- Which model applies (retention share, premium tier, disclosed platform fee), and does the owner agreement define every number?
- Are members told, in plain language where they'll see it, how the operator is paid?
- Does every introduction that earns me or the owner anything say so in the introduction itself?
- For a platform fee: is it billed through the owner's platform, never deducted by me? Have I kept it out of rooms where members' professional rules restrict sharing fees, or asked a lawyer first?
- Have I talked to a tax adviser about how fees and shares will be reported?
Before you launch a program
- For a paid tier: are the price and renewal terms clear at sign-up, are renewal reminders sent where required, and is cancelling as easy as joining? Has a lawyer who knows subscription rules reviewed the flow?
- Are curated offers disclosed when the owner or I am paid for them?
- For a group deal: does the owner consent, does each member contract and pay the supplier directly, and has anything I or the owner earn from the supplier been disclosed?
- For a placement: did the owner approve the sponsor in writing, is it labeled, and does the sponsor get only aggregate reports?
- For a giveaway: is it free to enter or awarded on stated skill criteria? If there's any payment, purchase or valuable prize, has a lawyer looked at it?
Before you join an operator alliance
- Is the alliance a working arrangement, never something sold to other operators?
- Is there a short written agreement listing what's shared and what never is?
- Do members move between rooms only by their own choice, with any referral thank-you disclosed and agreed by both owners?
- Are the operators staying away from pricing to owners and from dividing owners or niches between them, including never agreeing who pursues which owner?
- Do routed members stay in the sending room's record, with only de-identified patterns going into the operators' libraries?
When you hand a room back
- Has the owner had written notice?
- Are all accounts transferred and my access removed on the date?
- Has the member record gone back to the owner or been deleted, exactly as agreed, with written confirmation?
- Have members heard about the change from the owner, in the owner's voice?
- Are open deals, programs and final payments listed and settled?
- Is my pattern library free of anything that identifies a member or owner?
From The Un-Community: A Community Operator's Playbook by Bill Eisenhauer · Toll Stack Press · tollstack.dev/books/the-un-community/