← Tools Free Tool

Room Scorecard

When you size up a community, the first number anyone offers is headcount. It's the number that sounds impressive and says the least. A big room where members don't answer each other is a broadcast audience. A small room where members answer each other, help each other and do business with each other already has something to operate.

This scorecard is Chapter 3 of The Un-Community. Score a room 0, 1 or 2 on seven criteria, after an afternoon of reading as a guest or member, with the owner's permission. The total, out of 14, suggests what to do next. Headcount isn't one of the seven.

The room scorecard
Score the room, not the roster
0 is absent, 1 is some, 2 is strong. Judge patterns, not people, and copy nothing out of the room while you look.
1. Peer replies
Peer replies, 0 to 2
2. Repeat names
Repeat names, 0 to 2
3. A method
A method, 0 to 2
4. Owner presence
Owner presence, 0 to 2
5. Member spending
Member spending, 0 to 2
6. Platform fit
Platform fit, 0 to 2
7. Member mix
Member mix, 0 to 2
Red flags end it, whatever the score

Tick any you found. Some findings end the evaluation on their own.

Total 0 / 14

0 of 7 criteria scored

Score all seven criteria to see what the total suggests.
10–14

Worth a proposal.

6–9

Look closely at which scores are low. A weak method can be fixed with the owner, but an absent owner usually can't.

    0–5

    Walk away politely, however big the number on the roster.

    Member mix at 0. If that's because the room includes minors, it's a red flag on its own: tick it with the others. Rooms with minors are out of scope for the playbooks in this book.

    The thresholds are the book's rule of thumb, not measured data.

    Then ask the owner

    Reading gets you most of the way. A conversation with the owner gets you the rest, and these five questions do most of the work.

    • "What happens in the room when you're away for a week?" How much the room depends on one person.
    • "Who are the members you'd miss most if they left?" If the owner can name a dozen, there's a core. If they can't name anyone, there isn't.
    • "What have members done together that you didn't organize?" Referrals, collaborations, meetups. This is where the trading floor is hiding.
    • "What do you want the room to produce in a year?" Revenue, retention, a launch, a quieter inbox. You'll build differently for each.
    • "How much of your week can you give it, in writing?" The answer that matters most.
    Before you score

    Read a room's platform terms before you propose anything, and don't build what they forbid: no scraping, no automated messages the platform bans, no workarounds. Evaluate a room as a guest or member with the owner's permission, and don't copy member names, profiles or posts out of it while you look. What you're judging is patterns, not people.

    With the owner's permission and access the platform allows, an AI assistant can summarize a month of threads in minutes. Use that as a first pass and nothing more. A summary can count peer replies. It can't tell you whether the regulars are generous or cliquish, or whether the owner is loved or merely tolerated.

    Member spending is the criterion the book weighs above size: in its judgment, a few hundred members who spend seriously will outproduce many thousands who only watch. That's a judgment, not a statistic.

    Not legal, tax or financial advice. Running infrastructure inside someone else's community involves contracts, consumer-protection rules, privacy law and platform terms. Rooms with minors are out of scope for the playbooks in this book; ask a lawyer before operating one.

    The scorecard on one page
    The room scorecard: seven criteria, each scored 0 for absent, 1 for some or 2 for strong. Peer replies, from members rarely answering each other to most questions getting a member's answer first. Repeat names, from strangers in every thread to clear circles who know each other. A method, from opinions and inspiration to one the owner can explain in steps. Owner presence, from an owner who wants out to a committed, written schedule. Member spending, from no sign of it to members paying for tiers, tools or each other. Platform fit, from terms that forbid the work to clearly allowed. Member mix, from many minors or an off-limits field to adults who can legally do business together. Totals: 10 to 14 is worth a proposal; 6 to 9 means look at which scores are low, since a weak method can be fixed and an absent owner usually can't; 0 to 5 means walk away politely. A separate box lists red flags that end the evaluation whatever the score: all the content is the owner's and the owner is tired, no peer replies after a year, the platform forbids the work, the room includes minors, or the owner wants growth by any means. The thresholds are marked as the book's rule of thumb, not measured data.
    Figure 3.1 from the book. The printable version is in the reader kit.
    From The Un-Community

    This scorecard follows Chapter 3, "Reading a Room," of The Un-Community: A Community Operator's Playbook by Bill Eisenhauer. The chapter also covers what the score can't: why members came. A room full of people who arrived to learn something and use it this month can do something with a container or a trading floor. A room that's nearly all there for the owner's company wants hosting and ritual more than exchange, so price and scope for that.

    The score tells you where to spend your attention. It isn't a forecast of what a room will earn for anyone. The dollar figures in the book are illustrations; none of them is a promise, a projection or a typical outcome, and most people who try these methods earn little or nothing at first. Nothing on this page is saved or sent anywhere.